Homily at Our Lady of the Valleys for Holy Family, Year B.
One day, a man heard that a distant relative had died. Soon after, a package arrived, containing his unexpected inheritance: a violin and a painting. He sent them for valuation, and received the results: “What you have is a genuine Van Gogh and an original Stradivarius.” The heir was delighted and cried out: “I can sell these for millions!” The valuer stopped him “Not so fast, she said. Stradivarius wasn’t much of a painter… and Van Gogh made lousy violins.”
Inheritance! There are few topics with the power to bring so much hope and so much disappointment to families. You can hear Abraham’s disappointment at the thought he wouldn’t be able to pass on his wealth to his own son… and the power of the promise which God then made to him.
In the sixteen years I’ve been a priest, I’ve heard so many stories about lives ruined by disputes about inheritance. Someone was promised verbally that they would receive something, but this was never written into the Will. Or there was an assumption that a family member would divide up items of sentimental value a certain way, but that didn’t happen. The fallout can divide families for years, or forever.
Now I’m the first to recognise that when you expect to inherit something, it’s easy to daydream. My parents own a house, and when the time comes, its value will probably be split between my brother and myself. I could dream of a round-the-world holiday, or buying a brand-new car, or sponsoring some expensive charitable project. Or perhaps we’ll keep the house, or my brother will buy out my share. Yet maybe none of that will happen. Perhaps the house will have to be sold to pay for care home fees – or a survey might find an old mineshaft under its foundations and make it worthless. So I can dream, but I would be foolish to plan a future based on something I might never receive.
Yes, inheritance is beset by problems. Promises which are neither transparent nor fixed in writing. Hopes which may be dashed by circumstances. And cases where it’s not easy to see what a fair share looks like.
Imagine, for a moment, that you have four grown-up daughters.
- Angela never married, and has spent the last 20 years looking after you in your own home.
- Bridie married a teacher, but isn’t able to have any children.
- Christine married a very wealthy businessman, who is like another son to you. They have two children.
- Deborah defied your wishes and married a man with a criminal record who you thought was totally unsuitable. They have four children.
Now, it’s time to write your will. What do you do? Deborah’s family has the greatest needs: the children are nearly old enough for university. Christine’s children have all the money they need, but if you leave nothing to them, that will look mean. If you leave the house to Angela, there won’t be much money to donate to the rest of the family – but if you sell the house to give a share to each daughter or a share to each grandchild, where will Angela live? It would certainly seem unfair to make Angela homeless, but there are ways of leaving property “in trust” so its value can be shared out later.
I once used this example in another parish; a solicitor present told me afterwards that English Law would by default give equal shares to each daughter, but takes no account of grandchildren: “they are their parents’ responsibility”. His practical experience suggested that leaving grandchildren more than a token amount in a Will tends to cause conflict.
Sometimes there will be no easy answers – but there will be traps that we can avoid. Inheritance might not feel like a very Christmassy topic, but as we make New Year’s Resolutions this weekend we might want to include some good decisions which will avoid broken promises or shattered hopes. So here are some tips:
Be pro-active. None of us knows the day or hour when our Will will become effective. If you haven’t made one, your wishes surely won’t be carried out.
Be consistent. If you’ve made a promise that someone will receive something, take steps to make that official as soon as possible, by at least adding a codicil to your will. But if circumstances have changed and you’re not willing to keep the promise, it’s on you to walk it back in a way that minimises damage.
Be generous. Apply our Christian values and pray about the decisions you will need to make. A will is not a place to punish people – Jesus asks us not to judge others in this way.
Are you angry with a deceased relative for not including you in their will? Let it go. It was never your money in the first place. Pray for their soul!
Are you angry with a living relative for not sharing a portion of their inheritance with you? Let it go. They have had their reward already. Pray for their conversion!
Are you angry because the executor of a will is being slow to give you your inheritance? Let it go. God will allow your portion to come to you at a time when you’ll need it. Love and bless your adversary!
While you’re making your New Year Resultions, think also of the other crucial conversations which we put off having in families. Does your next of kin wish to be an organ donor? Do elderly parents need to put in place a Lasting Power of Attorney for healthcare or financial decisions? When will you have that conversation about burial or cremation, and whether you want Mass offered for your soul?
Today’s readings are also about promises being kept. God made good on the promise that Abraham would have a Son – and Mary and Joseph kept the Covenant by presenting Baby Jesus in the Temple. When it comes to arrangements for frailty and inheritance, we rely on others to carry our what was promised in good faith. To keep a promise is a sacred duty and, when done for our parents, is the keeping of one of the Ten Commandments. If we do the right thing by God, God will do the right thing by us. That’s a promise!